Home Culture ‘Ignorance is bliss mentality’: inside Florida’s ‘Disneyland for seniors’

‘Ignorance is bliss mentality’: inside Florida’s ‘Disneyland for seniors’


In the Villages, central Florida’s sprawling, master-planned retirement neighborhood billed as “Disneyland for seniors”, there may be one ubiquitous presence: the golf cart. The hybrid transport abounds throughout the Child Boomer mecca that’s now greater than Manhattan (and, from 2010-2017, the fastest-growing metropolitan area in america), zipping among the many advanced’s lush golf programs and filling its miniaturized parking spots.

The cart is sort of a personality unto itself in Some Sort of Heaven, Lance Oppenheim’s sly, remarkably open-hearted documentary on the Villages – it darts alongside postcard sunsets, previous indicators for “Florida’s friendliest residence city”, circles city squares and loops in a synchronized cart parade. The cart serves each a utilitarian goal – it’s a safer mode of transport than a automotive, particularly as most residents journey small distances – and the image of a fantasy: why have a automotive for those who by no means want to depart?

Some Sort of Heaven, the debut function from Oppenheim and executive-produced by director Darren Aronofsky, traces the define and underside of this arresting, distinctly American imaginative and prescient of marketable nostalgia, wherein seniors pay wherever from the low six figures for the promise of a everlasting trip. The Villages is “designed to cover all the issues of on a regular basis life”, Oppenheim informed the Guardian, and it’s a well-liked pitch: residents now quantity over 130,000. Designed to evoke the manicured streets and small-town familiarity of Reagan’s “morning in America” advert, it’s additionally a essentially conservative fantasy; over 98% of the residents are white, and Villagers voted overwhelmingly – almost 70% – for Trump in each 2016 and 2020.

That fantasy of sustained, uninterrupted consolation has its pull, which programs all through Some Sort of Heaven’s pictures of watercolor sunsets and seniors letting free to stay music. “There was one thing relatable about residing in a bubble,” stated Oppenheim, a south Florida native who started the mission in 2018 as a brief for his school thesis. But “there’s one thing deeply terrifying about the truth that it is a utopian/dystopian experiment that’s so wildly profitable that a complete demographic of individuals have chosen to stay inside one thing like this.”

In atmospheric, luxurious pictures that lean into the artifice of the city’s twilight visions, Some Sort of Heaven zips between actions that play like a university honest for seniors – martial arts instruction and majorettes, dance lessons and tambourine teams, pickleball and water aerobics, margarita mixers and dances any night time of the week. The convivial scenes provide a imaginative and prescient of life within the sundown years delightfully at odds with cultural assumption of outdated age – that it might be devoid of events, intercourse, medication, the capability for brand new hobbies — framed by palm bushes and watercolor skies, all whereas embroidering stated imaginative and prescient with the tribulations of 4 precise seniors who “name into query the advertising brochure fantasy”, Oppenheim stated.

The place different movies and investigations have centered on the Villages’ speedy, billion-dollar growth, its stark political fault-lines, or its ugly and really actual racism, Some Sort of Heaven slinks via the phantasm, tracing the currents of want, confusion and frustration that undercut it. “It’s very straightforward, clearly, to make any documentary topic, however particularly people who find themselves within the Villages, to look silly,” Oppenheim stated. “I needed to make a movie that was not about aged individuals; I simply needed to make a movie about individuals, whose needs to stay and specific themselves had been not likely that dissimilar to our personal.”

Filmed over 18 months between 2018 and 2019, Some Sort of Heaven primarily follows 4 seniors on the margin of the fantasy. Barbara, a widower from Boston, searches for connection via seemingly countless extracurricular choices and tires of the bubble’s efficiency of perpetual satisfaction. The bond between Reggie and Anne, married over 50 years, strains underneath Reggie’s derailing foray into medication, agnostically borrowed mysticism and slipping grip on actuality, as broadcast on his YouTube web page. Dennis, a roguish charmer into his 80s, prowls the Villages’ manicured streets in his van, reeling out his worn flirtation abilities for a feminine companion and, possibly, a backdoor into Village membership.

Dennis Dean
Dennis Dean. {Photograph}: Picture courtesy of Magnolia Photos.

The shifting sands of Reggie and Annie’s marriage, Barbara’s bonding over Jimmy Buffett with a possible suitor, display how, as Oppenheim put it, “there may be authenticity that may occur there, even in one of the inauthentically constructed locations ever.” Nonetheless the fantasy of secure areas and Mayberry-esque streets promotes an “ignorance is bliss mentality”, Oppenheim stated, “which actually can begin hovering over to only plain ignorance”.

In different phrases, the Villages’ usually vocal Republican allegiance. Quite a few journalistic options have documented the Villages’ increasingly hostile conservatism, its faux history, its comparatively small upwelling of liberal activism, its monetary ties to the GOP (billionaire founder H Gary Morse was one of many high Republican donors till his loss of life in 2014). This summer season, Villagers for Trump, a corporation of greater than 2,000 members, hosted a maskless, Covid-denial-filled event; a viral video, retweeted by Donald Trump, of one other Villagers for Trump rally captured a person shouting “white energy!” with fist within the air as he rolled previous a Panera bread in, sure, a golf cart.

However the Villages’ express, usually bumper-stickered political fault-lines by no means intrude on Some Sort of Heaven, which doesn’t a lot keep away from the topic as smudge the place’s basic conservatism – its concentrate on self-actualization via deliberate fantasy, its overwhelming whiteness, its six-figure barrier to entry – right into a haze of sunsets in paradise, swimming swimming pools and Parrothead events. Although Trump’s title isn’t talked about within the movie, “I wouldn’t name this an apolitical film,” Oppenheim stated. “I needed to make one thing that was extra engaged with the concepts of the Trump presidency, or a physique of people that do consider in these sorts of concepts that Trump believes in.” Make America Nice Once more does, in spite of everything, sprout from the identical bedrock of constructed nostalgia because the Villages’ movie-set Principal Road.

The “insane lengths individuals will go to to cocoon themselves inside a fantasy or a dream,” he added, “felt a lot extra instantly attention-grabbing and related … than simply making a ‘right here’s the Trump membership,’ ‘right here’s the Democrat membership,’ that is how they face off.”

Barbara Lochiatto
Barbara Lochiatto. {Photograph}: Picture courtesy of Magnolia Photos

Observing stated cocoon interprets right into a remarkably un-condescending film; there’s palpable pleasure to be present in scenes of conviviality between the individuals usually shunted to the margins of society, dismissed as dispensable by the various throughout the pandemic, whose interiority, development and capability for change is usually masked or ignored. The Villages could also be a homogeneous, Swiss cheese fantasy of the sundown years, however that doesn’t preclude the fantasy from holding some real revelations, usually captured in attentive, heat closeup – Barbara’s appearing class journey from passive viewers to self-excavating participant, Anne’s ginger steps towards an id exterior her husband and actually dancing on her personal in a crowd.

Finally, Oppenheim stated he noticed the mission as “type of a hopeful film”, that revels in the truth that “possibly in your eighth or ninth or seventh decade on this planet, you continue to could also be as scorching of a large number as you had been if you had been in your second decade on this planet, and that’s completely effective.”

Whether or not audiences discover that prospect miserable or soothing will depend on one’s private concept of what life may appear like when there’s assuredly much less time left on the clock than handed earlier than. However the imaginative and prescient, nevertheless restricted, of exploration and frivolity late in life suggestions towards hope. “Particularly proper now, when we have now a whole lot of time on our fingers and we’re caught inside and we have now to sort of discover methods to enhance our lives, I feel the search to raised your self is at all times a worthwhile one,” Oppenheim stated. “Seeing that for aged individuals ought to hopefully illustrate that time for everyone.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here